Honda vs. Kagawa
As befitting a three-day weekend occasioned by the ‘Health and Sports
Day’ holiday next Monday, Friday’s friendly match between Japan and Argentina
in Saitama will serve as the curtain-raiser to a mammoth few days of action
within the Japanese sporting calendar. Saturday sees both the close of the
regular season and the start of the play-offs in what, for now, probably remains
this country’s most popular team sport; with Seibu Lions opening their
best-of-three Climax Series tie with Lotte Marines in Nippon Professional
Baseball’s Pacific League hours before the parallel Central League completes
the last of its rain-delayed fixtures. Attention (both domestic and global) will
then shift to Suzuka Circuit in Mie Prefecture for the 16th round of the
Formula One World Championship, before Japanese eyes return to the baseball and
finally – once the minor hurdle of the first day back at work has been overcome
– to the Blue Samurai’s trip to fierce local rivals South Korea on Tuesday.
Though it remains hard for many to draw a line under a successful World
Cup that still feels like yesterday, the pair of international football matches
at the outer extremes of this extended weekend’s symmetry should properly
jumpstart the national team into its post-South Africa era. Following the state
of limbo that persisted throughout last
month’s friendlies with Paraguay and Guatemala under the caretaker charge
of Hiromi Hara, these two fixtures represent both the first for new manager
Alberto Zaccheroni and the last before Japan jet off to Qatar for the Asian Cup
in January. Tactically, the Italian must decide whether to respect the strength
of the opposition with a 4-3-3 (or 4-1-2-2-1) similar to that latterly employed
by Takeshi Okada, or to boldly test the limits of his newly-acquainted
charges in the 4-2-3-1 that looks likely to be his system of choice against
most continental sides in the next three years. Whichever way he goes, however,
Zaccheroni will also be forced to serve as adjudicator over a fascinating
battle for supremacy that has suddenly emerged over the past eight weeks.
When long-time key man Shunsuke Nakamura stepped out of his Celtic
comfort zone at the age of 31 to receive a rude awakening at Espanyol, Keisuke
Honda didn’t so much seize the initiative as brutally beat the last breaths out
of his sempai’s Japan career with it. 16 goals in a promotion-winning campaign
with VVV Venlo were immediately followed by a first international strike
against Chile in May 2009, six more goals in the Dutch top flight, and a
sensible move up to a CSKA Moscow side offering first-team football in the
Champions League. A couple more spectacular free kicks (against Anzhi Makhachkala and Sevilla) and an assured
showing against Internazionale later, few remained unconvinced that the
confident Osakan should be the
driving force around which the World Cup eleven were built. Even then, it
was still remarkable just how well he thrived on the challenge – bringing not only
crucial goals but excellent all-round play in an unfamiliar role as a Wilsonian
‘false
nine’.
In doing so, however, Honda’s ever ongoing quest for self-improvement
seems to have hit a plateau. Despite precious little opportunity for rest over
the preceding 12 months, the CSKA number seven flew straight back to Moscow
after the World Cup to resume the Russian domestic season with a cup derby
against Torpedo. He will stay for the remainder of the year to try and help his
team win the title – CSKA are currently third, albeit fully eight points behind
unbeaten leaders Zenit St. Petersburg – but it is clearly apparent that his
feet are growing itchier for a big-league challenge by the day. Whether through
form, fitness, or coach Leonid Slutsky’s recent tendency to force him back into
defensive midfield, Honda is now without a goal in 15 matches. Worse still, his
status as the headline-maker among Japanese players in Europe has suddenly been
usurped.
The impact made by Shinji Kagawa since transferring to Bundesliga giants
Borussia Dortmund is surely only enhanced by his
local reputation as ‘that bloke who was playing in the Japanese second
division six months ago’. But even to those of us around to witness him prove –
with 50 goals in two-and-a-third seasons from midfield – that he was always
destined for greater things, the 21-year-old’s progress has been astonishing. After
the disappointment of only travelling to South Africa as 24th man,
Kagawa settled into Germany immediately with a brace against FK Qarabağ in the
Europa League, before returning to Japan to score the only
goal against Paraguay. He then followed this up with another strike on his
home league debut against Wolfsburg, two in the Ruhr derby at Atsuto Uchida’s
Schalke 04, and yet another a week later at St. Pauli. While much of his
success at Cerezo Osaka came from the left of the attack, Dortmund manager Jürgen
Klopp has entrusted him with a central role behind the main striker. Like
Honda, Kagawa has made little secret of his desire to make the position his
own.
The competition can only be good for the national team. With Takayuki
Morimoto struggling to get games at Catania, Honda may well resume his World
Cup role this weekend with Kagawa on the left, but the cherished central berth
remains up for grabs if Zaccheroni opts to field them both behind a specialist
forward. In an ideal world, there will be a happy ending for everyone.
Instilling the attacking fluidity that characterises the best exponents of the
modern 4-2-3-1 requires time and patience, but once successful, would allow
both of Japan’s new stars to shine ever more brightly.
Permalink | Comments (5) | TrackBack (0)
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://app.cocolog-nifty.com/t/trackback/222697/49666460
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Honda vs. Kagawa:

Comments
-----------------------------------------------
Hellow!
I love your site, It is a pleasure to visit.
I have added your site to my site.
Please link my site to your site.
Thank you! (;_;)/~~~
http://ishigaki-island.blogspot.com/
----------------------------------------------
Posted by: | 10/10/2010 at 11:11 AM
After watching the Korea friendly, I don't think this is much of a competition. Honda's ability to hold the ball up and spread it around against a high pressure, physical team like Korea is 日本一.
Kagawa may have a flashier youtube reel than Honda this season, but Honda is much more crucial to the team.
Posted by: Absenteefan | 10/13/2010 at 05:13 AM
I think Kagawa's contribution in the Bundesliga so far has been much more comprehensive than a few YouTube highlights, but I'd certainly agree that Honda is both the more important and the more capable player right now. Kagawa remains a little raw - though remarkably mature in light of his inexperience - while Honda's game is more rounded and consistent. He may not enjoy it, but he has probably gained a fair bit from playing in defensive midfield for CSKA.
It's still a turn of 'your move, Keisuke', though. His status in the national team was never going to be overturned in just two months, but while Kagawa continues to make leaps and bounds in what is probably now the third league in Europe ahead of Serie A, Honda will need to step up and polish his skills at a higher level too. If not, he is at risk of stagnation while the gap between the pair decreases further.
Still, all good news for Japan as I say, and it was nice to see again last night that Honda was disciplined enough to go left when Kagawa dropped into the centre, and vice versa.
Posted by: Ben Mabley | 10/13/2010 at 11:31 AM
Unless Kagawa ascends to Messian heights, I just don't see him surpassing Honda in importance to the national team.
Now when I say this, I don't mean that Kagawa has no chance of becoming a better overall player. Frankly, I think it's a pretty close contest even now.
What I do mean is that Honda’s talents are irreplaceable. Japanese teams will always face a deficit in size and power at international level. Facing bigger and stronger teams who try to press this advantage, the value for Japan of having at least one player with the strength and technique to maintain possession as well as provide an outlet for under-pressure teammates is magnified. Moreover, Japan has a hard time producing players of this type.
In contrast, Kagawa seems to me to be a very Japanese footballer. The “shape” of his skills – excellent technique, movement, and combination play – is far from unique. While players of this type are obviously useful (and I do think Kagawa is something special), I’m far more confident that Japan will continue to produce high quality 170 cm attacking midfielders than I am that Japan will produce another player like Honda.
Posted by: Absenteefan | 10/13/2010 at 01:16 PM
A woman’s place is in the home.
Posted by: Tadalis preis | 02/25/2011 at 05:58 AM